Guide: Theater shows on Long Island

Do you want to see a theater show but don't want to travel into New York City? Look no further. Here is a guide for some shows playing on Long Island. Please check with the theater before heading out. Dates and times are subject to change.
NOTE: COVID-19 guidelines and protocols, such as masks or vaccine requirements, maybe in place. Please check with the theaters ahead of time.

UPCOMING SHOWS

Sept. 10-Oct. 9
Kinky Boots

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information 
Sept. 15-30
Mystic Pizza

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information
Sept. 15-Oct. 23
An American in Paris

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information
Sept. 17-Oct. 22
Guys & Dolls

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
Sept. 17-Oct 1
Cabaret

CM Performing Arts Center
Oakdale
More Information 
Sept. 24-Oct. 9
Guys & Dolls

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
Sept. 30-Oct. 29
The Lightning Thief

Smithtown Center for the Performing Arts
Smithtown
More Information 
Oct. 15-Nov. 5
Matilda The Musical

CM Performing Arts Center
Oakdale
More Information 
Oct. 16-29
Pinkalicious

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information 
Oct. 22-Nov. 13
Big Fish

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information 
Nov. 10-Jan. 1, 2023
Beauty & the Beast

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information
Nov. 11-12
Fiddler on the Roof

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information
Nov. 11-13
Willy Wonka

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Nov. 12-Dec. 30
A Christmas Carol

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
Nov. 17-Jan. 1, 2023
A Christmas Story

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
Nov. 19-Dec. 4
Grumpy Old Men The Musical

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Nov. 19-Dec. 18
The Wizard of Oz

CM Performing Arts Center
Oakdale
More Information 
Nov. 26
Willy Wonka

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Dec. 3-17
Jack Frost

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Dec. 10
Legally Blonde - The Musical

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information
Dec. 10-11
Jack Frost

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information 
Dec. 16-28
A Christmas Carol

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
Dec. 17
Scrooge

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information  
Dec. 17-18
The Nutcracker

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information 
Dec. 17-23
Elf

Madison Theater at Molloy University
1000 Hempstead Ave.
Rockville Centre
More Information 
Dec. 18
Scrooge

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Dec. 27-29
Disney’s Beauty & the Beast

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information 
Dec. 30-31
Disney’s Beauty & the Beast

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 

2023

Jan. 14-Feb. 4, 2023
The Sweet Deliah Swim Club

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information 
Jan. 14-Feb. 19
Rocky

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information
Jan. 19-March 5
Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
Jan. 27-Feb. 26
The Wedding Singer

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
Feb. 9-April 2
West Side Story

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information 
Feb. 15-18
Branching Out

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information 
Feb. 18-March 18
Side by Side by Sondheim

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
Feb. 20-26
Cinderella

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Feb. 22-25
Cinderella

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
March 4-April 2
Ragtime The Musical

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information 
March 11-19
The Cat in the Hat

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
March 16-April 30
The Scarlet Pimpernel

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
March 17-April 16
Clue

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
March 18-April 2
Forever Plaid

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
March 25-April 1
The Cat in the Hat

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
April 7-May 6
Pride & Prejudice 

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information 
April 8
Winnie the Pooh

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information 
April 12
The Wizard of Oz

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
April 14-16
The Wizard of Oz

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information 
April 27-June 18
Rock of Ages

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information
May 18-June 2
The Sound of Music

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
May 20-June 4
Mama Mia!

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
May 20-June 24
Something Rotten

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
July 6-Aug. 27
Grease

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information 
July 13-Aug. 27
Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information

PAST SHOWS

July 15-Aug. 1
All Shook Up
Madison Theatre at Molloy University
1000 Hempstead Ave.
Rockville Centre
More Information
July 15-Aug. 7
The Little Mermaid

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
July 23-Aug. 6
Beauty & the Beast Jr.

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
July 14-Aug. 28
Footloose: The Musical

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information
July 23-Aug. 21
Newsies

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information
Aug. 4-14
I Love You, You’re Perfect, Now Change

Smithtown Center for the Performing Arts
Smithtown
More Information 
Aug. 6-20
Bye Bye Birdie

CM Performing Arts Center
Oakdale
More Information
Aug. 19-20
Jeff Boyer’s Big Bubble Bonanza 

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
July 14-Sept. 3
Get On Your Feet!

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information
Aug. 27-Sept. 4
Run For Your Wife

The Manes Studio Theatre
141 S. Wellwood Ave.
Lindenhurst
More Information
Aug. 26-Sept. 11
The Cher Show

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
Aug. 18-Sept. 12
Ella, First Lady of Song

Madison Theater at Molloy University
1000 Hempstead Ave.
Rockville Centre
More Information
Did we miss your favorite show or theater? Click here and let us know!