Preston Taylor sentenced to 18 years for role in Sarah Stern's murder

A Monmouth County man will serve at least 13 years in prison for his admitted role in the murder of a former high school classmate.

News 12 Staff

Jun 28, 2019, 11:57 AM

Updated 1,768 days ago

Share:

A Monmouth County man will serve at least 13 years in prison for his admitted role in the murder of a former high school classmate.
Preston Taylor was sentenced to 18 years in prison Friday after he admitted to helping his friend and roommate Liam McAtasney dispose of the body of Sarah Stern – their friend since childhood.
Taylor pleaded guilty to his role in the crime as part of a plea deal and testified for the prosecution in McAtasney’s trial. Taylor admitted to helping McAtasney throw Stern’s body off the Route 35 Bridge in Belmar after McAtasney killed Stern in order to steal money she recently found. The two men left Stern’s car on the bridge to stage her disappearance to look like a suicide.
McAtasney was convicted of the murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Taylor spoke at his sentencing hearing and apologized to the Stern’s family.
“I should have known better and done something to stop this. I wish I had. I’m sorry,” he said.
But Stern’s father, Michael Stern, did not wish to hear Taylor’s words and walked out of the courtroom.
“I don’t want to hear anything from him. He had the opportunity – he had many opportunities…to stop it. He had the opportunity not to participate. There's nothing good there. It's evil, just evil,” said Michael Stern.
Taylor was to receive no more than 20 years in prison as part of the deal to testify against McAtasney. He received 18 with the possibility of parole in 13 years.
Michael Stern said that he wished the sentenced was longer.
“That’s part of the justice system, tough to deal with. It doesn’t bring Sarah back,” he said.
Michael Stern says that he is now focusing on setting up a scholarship in his daughter’s name to keep her memory alive.


More from News 12
Trial begins for man accused of killing Stamford man in Bridgeport in 2017

Trial begins for man accused of killing Stamford man in Bridgeport in 2017

2:20
 Weather brings in warmer temps in Connecticut, risk of showers

Weather brings in warmer temps in Connecticut, risk of showers

0:28
Community college in Bridgeport hosts symposium to assist people impacted by criminal justice system

Community college in Bridgeport hosts symposium to assist people impacted by criminal justice system

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:44
Sen. Blumenthal calls for investigation into TurboTax for deceptive marketing practices

Sen. Blumenthal calls for investigation into TurboTax for deceptive marketing practices

1:58
New Haven police take down Yale students' encampment amid pro-Palestinian protests

New Haven police take down Yale students' encampment amid pro-Palestinian protests

0:44
UConn police tear down pro-Palestinian encampments, some protesters arrested

UConn police tear down pro-Palestinian encampments, some protesters arrested

1:39
Fairfield students to compete in Odyssey of the Mind world finals

Fairfield students to compete in Odyssey of the Mind world finals

0:18
Pickup truck crashes into porch at Bridgeport home

Pickup truck crashes into porch at Bridgeport home

0:25
Abandoned tan pit bull escapes in Norwalk, authorities seek information

Abandoned tan pit bull escapes in Norwalk, authorities seek information

0:24
Bridgeport Mayor Joe Ganim joins nationwide discussion of homelessness at the White House

Bridgeport Mayor Joe Ganim joins nationwide discussion of homelessness at the White House

0:23
E-ZPass warns of text message scam targeting customers

E-ZPass warns of text message scam targeting customers

3:08
Made in Connecticut: Tucci Lumber Bats in Norwalk makes bats for Major League Baseball

Made in Connecticut: Tucci Lumber Bats in Norwalk makes bats for Major League Baseball

8:55
Guide: Ways to set your child up for financial success

Guide: Ways to set your child up for financial success

0:17
Stratford PD: Elementary school student displayed knife at classmate during an argument

Stratford PD: Elementary school student displayed knife at classmate during an argument

0:54
Police: Ansonia man accused of murdering Bridgeport teen

Police: Ansonia man accused of murdering Bridgeport teen

2:27
Gov. Lamont assumes responsibility for removal of trees in an environmentally protected area near his Greenwich home

Gov. Lamont assumes responsibility for removal of trees in an environmentally protected area near his Greenwich home

1:59
Road between Darien, Norwalk causes safety concerns following crash into water

Road between Darien, Norwalk causes safety concerns following crash into water

2:13
New parking rules in downtown Westport to take effect May 1

New parking rules in downtown Westport to take effect May 1

0:29
Pilot program at Bridgeport Hospital helps families with newborns

Pilot program at Bridgeport Hospital helps families with newborns