Neptune City resident Preston Taylor admits helping to dispose of missing friend Sarah Stern’s body

<p>A judge accepted a plea agreement Monday for one of two men accused in the death of missing 19-year-old Neptune City resident Sarah Stern, according to the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office. Officials said Preston Taylor, 19, pleaded guilty in front of Monmouth County Judge Richard English.</p>

News 12 Staff

Apr 24, 2017, 8:29 PM

Updated 2,570 days ago

Share:

Neptune City resident Preston Taylor admits helping to dispose of missing friend Sarah Stern’s body
The childhood friend of a missing Neptune City teen admitted to helping to dispose of her body after she was killed.
Preston Taylor, 19, accepted a plea deal and admitted in court Monday that he helped throw 19-year-old Sarah Stern’s body off the Route 35 Bridge into the Shark River in December 2016. 
Taylor pleaded guilty to six counts against him, including first-degree robbery, second-degree conspiracy to commit robbery, and second-degree disturbing or desecrating human remains.
Taylor told Judge Richard English that his friend Liam McAtasney learned that Stern had recently come into $10,000. Taylor also said that the two planned to rob her of the money and that McAtasney was going to kill her.
“[McAtasney] strangled her and hid her body in a downstairs bathroom,” Taylor said in court.
Authorities say McAtasney called Taylor after Stern was dead to ask him to help move the body and throw it into the Shark River. Taylor was allegedly offered $3,000 for his help.
Taylor also admitted to leaving Stern’s car on the bridge in an attempt to make her disappearance look like a suicide. Stern’s body has not yet been recovered.
Taylor will be required to testify against McAtasney as part of the plea deal. A grand jury indicted McAtasney Monday.
Taylor is expected to be sentenced July 21. He is facing 10 to 20 years in prison.


More from News 12
2:20
Officials eye plan to charge for on-street parking in New Canaan to solve parking complaints

Officials eye plan to charge for on-street parking in New Canaan to solve parking complaints

1:29
Afternoon welcomes sunshine and temps pushing 80 degrees to Connecticut

Afternoon welcomes sunshine and temps pushing 80 degrees to Connecticut

1:58
Residents at Bridgeport's Greene Homes community to be part of planning process for new complex

Residents at Bridgeport's Greene Homes community to be part of planning process for new complex

0:26
Freight train catches fire in Stamford; Metro-North now operating on or close to schedule

Freight train catches fire in Stamford; Metro-North now operating on or close to schedule

Deadline to get a Real ID is May 7, 2025. Here's how to get one in Connecticut.

Deadline to get a Real ID is May 7, 2025. Here's how to get one in Connecticut.

1:43
Garden Guide: These plants repel weeds and are a natural fertilizer!

Garden Guide: These plants repel weeds and are a natural fertilizer!

2:46
8 tips for children walking or bicycling to school

8 tips for children walking or bicycling to school

2:20
Connecticut's workforce celebrates new legislation guaranteeing paid sick time

Connecticut's workforce celebrates new legislation guaranteeing paid sick time

0:32
Police: Man wanted for Torrington bank robbery

Police: Man wanted for Torrington bank robbery

2:23
Stew Leonard’s considers 2nd attempt at bringing store to Orange

Stew Leonard’s considers 2nd attempt at bringing store to Orange

2:21
Stamford man recovers from rare Rocky Mountain spotted fever

Stamford man recovers from rare Rocky Mountain spotted fever

2:43
EXCLUSIVE: Bridgeport truck driver whose flatbed was struck in fiery I-95 crash says he’s grateful to be alive

EXCLUSIVE: Bridgeport truck driver whose flatbed was struck in fiery I-95 crash says he’s grateful to be alive

0:53
Bridgeport plans to restore the Perry Memorial Arch

Bridgeport plans to restore the Perry Memorial Arch

0:30
Little Feat to headline Milford’s 50th Oyster Festival

Little Feat to headline Milford’s 50th Oyster Festival

0:41
US provides $3 million relief funding toward reconstructing Fairfield Avenue Bridge in Norwalk

US provides $3 million relief funding toward reconstructing Fairfield Avenue Bridge in Norwalk

0:42
AT&T lauds nearly $500M investment in network infrastructure across Connecticut

AT&T lauds nearly $500M investment in network infrastructure across Connecticut

0:32
'Be careful when you're on your cellphone'. Bridgeport officials relay safety message following pedestrian accidents

'Be careful when you're on your cellphone'. Bridgeport officials relay safety message following pedestrian accidents

0:30
CT lawmakers vote to extend sick days to nearly all workers; bill heads to governor's desk

CT lawmakers vote to extend sick days to nearly all workers; bill heads to governor's desk

1:43
Made in Connecticut: Fresh squeezed juice from Ripe Juice Bar

Made in Connecticut: Fresh squeezed juice from Ripe Juice Bar

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers