News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Sunny
64°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

New evidence will support case for New Fairfield man accused in fatal dog shooting, attorney says

Gary Benicewicz was charged after shooting a chocolate lab named JoJo back in May.

Mark Sudol

•

Nov 3, 2023, 5:36 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The attorney for a New Fairfield man accused of fatally shooting his neighbor’s dog says he is withdrawing an application for accelerated rehabilitation that would have wiped his client’s record clean, citing new evidence he says will support his case.

Gary Benicewicz was charged after shooting a chocolate lab named JoJo back in May. His attorney Greg Miller says his client is traumatized by what happened and acted in self-defense that day on Diana Drive in New Fairfield. Miller says he has proof that Jojo has left her yard before and attacked others. He says Jojo was a deeply troubled dog.

"There are very substantial facts on my client's side that are inconsistent with perhaps what has been told to the media," said Miller.

Jojo's owner Lisa Pierce-Wirth and her family told News 12 Connecticut that Jojo, a rescue dog, was taking anxiety medication. Still, they don't believe it gave Benicewicz the right to do what he did.

"This was his decision despite he knew that this was our family dog and despite the fact that he knew he was in a residential neighborhood," said Pierce-Wirth.

Pierce-Wirth believes Benicewicz went out of his way to target Jojo.

"He kept coming back until she got off the property so that he could shoot her," said Pierce-Wirth.

Miller says no matter what happens in this case, this was a tragedy for everyone.

There is a pre-trial hearing next month where attorney Miller will present evidence to support his client's case.

Top Stories

00:46
Gambling Issues MS 091626_2026-09-16-17-41-49

Blumenthal calls for action against predatory AI features on sports betting apps

01:17
CT TODAY

Beautiful day before showers arrive tomorrow in Connecticut

01:29
Screenshot 2026-10-02 211448

'Not too far from the school.' Bridgeport police investigating incident involving multiple people taken into custody

01:10
CT RECCHIA BEAUTY QUEEN ARTIST - 7AM_2026-10-03-09-54-46

From the crown to the canvas: Former Ms. Connecticut invites public to attend solo art exhibit

02:00
d5828906-02ae-43b6-b2b4-175f75d8d145

Judge orders DNA sample from Danbury woman charged in 2018 newborn death case

01:32
Screenshot 2026-10-02 162703

Funeral held in Bridgeport for CT DOT worker killed by alleged impaired driver

02:07
Screenshot 2026-10-02 210320

New ICE restrictions start this week. Can Connecticut enforce them?

00:20
DEATH INVESTIGATION

Wellness check at Woodbridge home prompts police death investigation

00:28
flockcameracrackdownbillCM_2026-10-02-16-45-15

New bill seeks to ban federal use of Flock license plate readers

00:24
botcat2

CAUGHT ON CAMERA: Bobcat spotted in front of Norwalk home

CREDIT: AP PHOTO

CBS announces Tony Romo's permanent exit following arrest for operating a vehicle while intoxicated

Drugs

Suspected Norwalk dealers busted with trove of drugs during traffic stop

00:31
cat file photo

Investigation finds heavy metals in nearly all cat food

car crash generic

New Haven man convicted of evading responsibility in crash killing 17-year-old

00:46
102eastend_2026-10-02-06-24-08

The East End: Wine Barn & Farmers Market

00:25
shelton armed robbery

Police: Trumbull man charged in connection to Shelton armed robbery

01:40
cartrighttowersmeetingCM_2026-10-01-21-21-19

Cartright Towers residents attend flood mitigation meeting in Fairfield, demand answers

00:28
pizzalotto_2026-10-01-21-43-27

CT Lottery teams up with 3 iconic pizzerias for limited-run scratch game

00:44
Screenshot 2026-10-01 at 9.47.21 PM

Stratford fire chief concludes 25-year career with the department, starts new chapter

00:29
Screenshot 2026-10-01 212910

Fairfield police support people fighting breast cancer with annual Pink Pledge

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices