News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

New evidence will support case for New Fairfield man accused in fatal dog shooting, attorney says

Gary Benicewicz was charged after shooting a chocolate lab named JoJo back in May.

Mark Sudol

Nov 3, 2023, 5:36 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The attorney for a New Fairfield man accused of fatally shooting his neighbor’s dog says he is withdrawing an application for accelerated rehabilitation that would have wiped his client’s record clean, citing new evidence he says will support his case.

Gary Benicewicz was charged after shooting a chocolate lab named JoJo back in May. His attorney Greg Miller says his client is traumatized by what happened and acted in self-defense that day on Diana Drive in New Fairfield. Miller says he has proof that Jojo has left her yard before and attacked others. He says Jojo was a deeply troubled dog.

"There are very substantial facts on my client's side that are inconsistent with perhaps what has been told to the media," said Miller.

Jojo's owner Lisa Pierce-Wirth and her family told News 12 Connecticut that Jojo, a rescue dog, was taking anxiety medication. Still, they don't believe it gave Benicewicz the right to do what he did.

"This was his decision despite he knew that this was our family dog and despite the fact that he knew he was in a residential neighborhood," said Pierce-Wirth.

Pierce-Wirth believes Benicewicz went out of his way to target Jojo.

"He kept coming back until she got off the property so that he could shoot her," said Pierce-Wirth.

Miller says no matter what happens in this case, this was a tragedy for everyone.

There is a pre-trial hearing next month where attorney Miller will present evidence to support his client's case.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:04
Child struck by jetski in Shelton

Out-of-control Jet Ski strikes child at Indian Well State Park in Shelton

01:53
F P2 PM

Summer is here early for Western Connecticut

01:24
RTCTBpt2ndHomicideOf2026FRecchia9pm_2026-05-17-21-20-59

Bridgeport family 'crushed' following fatal shooting of 25-year-old man

00:24
Fatal Accident

Bridgeport scooter rider killed in car collision

00:26
fatal crash - mon copy (1)

One person dead, two injured after New Haven car crash

02:43
RTGOPFazioNominationFRecchia6pm_2026-05-16-18-27-02

Fazio wins Republican nomination for governor in 'landslide' delegate vote

00:52
NED LAMONT GENERIC

Gov. Ned Lamont accepts Democratic endorsement for state governor

00:16
FIRE INVESTIGATION

Bridgeport fire displaces 10 people

00:24
SHOOTING INVESTIGATION generic MONITOR copy

One person killed, another injured in Bridgeport shooting

00:24
Scam Alert - MON copy

New Canaan police warn residents about unpaid traffic ticket text scam

03:27
LIRR Strike

LIRR UPDATES: LIRR union leader says bargaining talks with the MTA will resume Monday morning as LIRR strike enters Day 3

01:52
justinpkg0515_2026-05-15-21-22-12

Outdoor wellness group helps first responders, veterans cope with mental health struggles

02:34
0515CRAVENStewartPKG_2026-05-15-16-39-28

'A time of unity.' CT Republicans look to move on from Erin Stewart scandal at convention

00:56
volunteer0515_2026-05-15-21-16-48

Longtime Westport resident honored for his commitment and service

01:06
nationalreadingmonth7amshow051626_2026-05-16-07-21-54

Waltersville Elementary School celebrate National Get Caught Reading Month

01:22
9b659edd-46e3-4d28-a1f0-a5cc1131de62

Crescent moon pairs with Venus and Jupiter in evening sky next week

gavel-generic-court-thumbnail

Department of Justice files lawsuit against Connecticut and state officials over legislation restricting ICE

01:51
leannapkg0515_2026-05-15-17-50-29

Stamford Hospital hosts annual research day geared toward improving patient care

00:53
penfield0515_2026-05-15-17-05-58

Fairfield's Penfield Reef designated as a vertical flight heritage site

00:53
JohnMadukotn

Former CSCU chancellor sent sexually explicit texts for two years, new records reveal

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices