Defense argues driver in deadly crash was too high to understand rights

The defense attorney for a driver accused of crashing into a Passaic County gas station, killing three people, wasn't in any condition to voluntarily waive his rights when questioned.

News 12 Staff

Oct 29, 2019, 2:10 AM

Updated 1,652 days ago

Share:

The defense attorney for a driver accused of crashing into a Passaic County gas station, killing three people, wasn't in any condition to voluntarily waive his rights when questioned.
Jason Vanderee is charged with aggravated manslaughter and death by auto while intoxicated in the Feb. 19 crash at a Delta gas station on Route 23 in Wayne that killed 50-year-old Jon Warbeck, his 17-year-old son Luke and gas station attendant Lovedeep Fatra. Passaic County prosecutors say heroin and a needle were found in the vehicle.
While handcuffed inside St. Joseph's Hospital, Vanderee was questioned by a detective who had a warrant for blood and urine.
Defense attorney John Latoracca would not agree to be interviewed on camera but told News 12 New Jersey that he questions if Vanderee was clear-headed enough after the crash to understand his Miranda Rights. He says that he is arguing a motion that what his client may have said at the time should not be admissible in court.
Criminal defense attorney Ken Vercammen is not involved in this case but tells News 12 that he thinks that the defense could win the motion.
"In court, someone wouldn't be permitted to plead guilty to something if they were under the influence,” he says. “How can you waive something that you don't really understand what's going on?"
At a previous court hearing, Detective Michael Polifrone testified that Vanderee was sitting up in bed and alert. But also noted he appeared high on drugs and seemed to nod off.
"Typically, smart, coherent people would say ‘No, I’m not going to waive my rights so I can get to go to prison for many years,’” Vercammen says.
The judge will also need to rule on if comments Vanderee made to an EMT and a doctor will they be allowed at trial.
Vercammen says that Miranda Rights only apply to law enforcement officers.
“Probably the defendant has a loser as far as trying to keep out anything he said to the EMT,” Vercammen says.
Vercammen says medical records will help the judge make the ruling. Those records will be able to show what the Vanderee may have been high on and how extreme that high was. It'll also show what he may have been given by the hospital staff. Those records have been requested from the hospital.
Vanderee’s next court date will be in November. The judge will have to decide if he'll allow jurors to hear evidence of a crash Vanderee was involved in back in 2016 on Route 80.
The Associated Press wire services contributed to this report.


More from News 12
2:43
EXCLUSIVE: Bridgeport truck driver whose flatbed was struck in fiery I-95 crash says he’s grateful to be alive

EXCLUSIVE: Bridgeport truck driver whose flatbed was struck in fiery I-95 crash says he’s grateful to be alive

2:22
Mild and muggy in Connecticut; rain returns by midweek

Mild and muggy in Connecticut; rain returns by midweek

1:43
Saravanaa Bhavan a restaurant serving Indian vegetarian cuisine opens in Stamford

Saravanaa Bhavan a restaurant serving Indian vegetarian cuisine opens in Stamford

Former Bridgeport official pleads guilty to charges related to primaries and election in 2017, 2018

Former Bridgeport official pleads guilty to charges related to primaries and election in 2017, 2018

2:11
Security camera footage shows onset of deadly Stamford house fire

Security camera footage shows onset of deadly Stamford house fire

1:48
'This was a remarkable recovery': I-95 officially operating at full capacity

'This was a remarkable recovery': I-95 officially operating at full capacity

0:36
Sen. Bob Duff recognizes employees who worked on reopening I-95 in Norwalk

Sen. Bob Duff recognizes employees who worked on reopening I-95 in Norwalk

0:20
Bridgeport PD: Pedestrian struck by car on Seaview Avenue

Bridgeport PD: Pedestrian struck by car on Seaview Avenue

1:05
National Water Safety Month: 40,000 free swim lessons offered across tri-state area offered across tri-state area

National Water Safety Month: 40,000 free swim lessons offered across tri-state area offered across tri-state area

0:36
Sen. Blumenthal to seek emergency help for Norwalk businesses impacted by I-95 shutdown

Sen. Blumenthal to seek emergency help for Norwalk businesses impacted by I-95 shutdown

0:56
Nonprofit builders group celebrates 20th anniversary with annual fundraiser in Darien

Nonprofit builders group celebrates 20th anniversary with annual fundraiser in Darien

0:49
Mother’s Day event in Greenwich looks to empower women

Mother’s Day event in Greenwich looks to empower women

0:59
Pickleball America hosts first Dinko de Mayo Tournament

Pickleball America hosts first Dinko de Mayo Tournament

2:15
Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Connecticut National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

Connecticut National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

0:42
Texas, prolific retired Connecticut State Police K-9, dies from illness

Texas, prolific retired Connecticut State Police K-9, dies from illness

0:44
Handball tournament honors former Bridgeport state representative

Handball tournament honors former Bridgeport state representative

0:30
Zibanejad has 2 goals and 1 assist, Panarin scores as Rangers beat Hurricanes 4-3 in Game 1

Zibanejad has 2 goals and 1 assist, Panarin scores as Rangers beat Hurricanes 4-3 in Game 1

2:06
New guidance says women need to be screened for breast cancer at 40 or younger

New guidance says women need to be screened for breast cancer at 40 or younger

0:34
State police: Merging car collided with tanker to cause I-95 overpass fire

State police: Merging car collided with tanker to cause I-95 overpass fire