News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

Family of dancer who died after eating cookie files lawsuit against Stew Leonard's, cookie manufacturer

Orla Baxendale died in January after she ate Florentine Cookies at a social gathering.

Rose Shannon

May 24, 2024, 11:05 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The family of a woman who died from an allergic reaction after eating cookies sold by Stew Leonard's filed a wrongful death lawsuit in Connecticut Superior Court Thursday.

The parents of Orla Baxendale filed the suit against Stew Leonard's and 11 of its employees, along with Cookies United, the Long Island bakery that manufactured the cookies.

Baxendale, 25, died in January after she ate Florentine Cookies at a social gathering.

As News 12 reported, the Florentine Cookies were sold at the Stew Leonard's in Danbury and Newington.

The cookies contained peanuts, but were not listed on the label.

The grocery store claimed Cookies United did not inform them of a change in ingredients. However the company says they sent an email to 11 Stews employees about the change last summer, months before the cookies were sold.

The cookies were later recalled by The Connecticut Department of Consumer Protection because they also contained undeclared eggs.

Director of Public Relations Meghan Bell provided the following comment to News 12:

I'm sorry, but on the advice of our legal counsel, we can't comment on pending litigation.

More Stories

Top Stories

00:28
norwalkcar0605_2026-06-05-21-04-21

Police ask for public's help identifying vehicle involved in Norwalk hit-and-run

02:22
Screenshot 2026-06-05 173523

Summer heat leads to nasty evening storms on Saturday

02:03
justinpkg0605_2026-06-05-21-10-18_21-07-38,01

Fairfield woman charged with arson after setting multi-family home on fire, police say

00:24
QUrugby0605_2026-06-05-21-27-24

Quinnipiac University women’s rugby team files Title IX complaint over program being demoted

02:20
marissapkg0605_2026-06-05-16-37-40

Police: Two men entered Milford home while couple slept, killed one, wounded other

HATE CRIME CHARGES MONITOR copy

Fairfield resident arraigned in connection to NYU graduation hate crime

02:10
0605PrivatelawlistingCraven_2026-06-05-16-43-02

House hunting? New state law could mean more real estate listings

00:33
stratfordcoachcharges0605_2026-06-05-16-39-04

Police: Second former student accuses of ex-Stratford wrestling coach of sexual assault

00:21
Arrest Made Generic

Trumbull Police arrest man after disrupting pride ceremony

00:24
marissapkg105_2026-01-05-17-25-02_16-32-43,06

Court document says Michelle Troconis will appeal habeas petition denial

02:19
Screenshot 2026-06-05 125144

Sherwood Island State Park pavilion to be closed for at least the entire 2026 season

00:58
milfordupdate0604_2026-06-04-21-03-32

Police: Milford homicide was a targeted attack

00:27
ICE ARREST MONITOR copy

Officials: Multiple people arrested by ICE officers in Danbury

03:03
marissapkg0604_2026-06-04-21-36-46_21-09-51,01

Animal sanctuary created in Sandy Hook girl’s memory marks milestone celebration Saturday

01:59
justinpkg0604_2026-06-04-21-21-03

'Nothing like this exists.' Darien cancer surivor, Greenwich teen create app for cancer patients, caregivers

00:28
HATE CRIME CHARGES MONITOR copy

Fairfield resident arrested in connection to NYU graduation hate crime

00:16
blue ribbon school box copy

New Milford police investigate alleged inappropriate communicating between school employee and student

02:19
erinstewart0413_2026-04-13-21-13-06

'I'm due this.' Erin Stewart demanded 'shocking' $205,000 payout, report shows

00:55
humantraffickingpanel0604_2026-06-04-16-36-24

Human trafficking awareness panel held at the Ferguson Library

00:50
planecrash0604_2026-06-04-16-48-03

Plane slams into fence at Danbury Airport after failed takeoff

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices