After weighing several options, the Connecticut State Department of Transportation announced at a Town Hall that it plans to replace the 140-year-old Cribari Bridge by building a new one in the same spot.
Unlike the current version, it would be tall enough to handle 18-wheel tractor-trailers.
"It would be catastrophic," said Shannon Taylor, who lives near the bridge. "My kids stand a foot from the curb to get to the bus."
"Whether you take a left or right on Riverside Avenue, you can't take a turn with a tractor-trailer efficiently," added Ward French, who chairs the town's Cribari Bridge Advisory Committee.
The state's original plans called for the new bridge to be 16 feet, 3 inches high.
However at the Town Hall, it was said instead that it would only be 13 feet, 10 inches high.
"It is a bit of a compromise that they lowered it, unfortunately it's not enough," said Gail Coykendall, who represents the area as one of District 1's RTM representatives.
The current bridge was built in 1884 and last had renovations in the early 1990s.
As part of the state's presentation, pictures were shown of the deterioration of both the steel and concrete.
The clearance is currently 12-foot-seven. To stop tractor-trailers, the new one can be no taller than 13 feet, 4 inches high.
"(Lowering the height more) would increase the risk of vehicle strikes and could create additional safety concerns," said DOT project manager James Barrows at the meeting.
"That's a smaller risk than semis coming down the street where there's kids on the sidewalk scootering and on their front yard," replied Taylor.
However, the state claimed in its presentation that the new, bigger bridge would not lead to an increase in traffic.
Neighbors however, said they did not buy that - considering the bridge runs parallel to Interstate 95 and is visible from the highway.
"When there's a bad accident on 95 and everyone gets rerouted, they come this direction," Coykendall said.
Even if the new bridge is built as proposed, the town could still ban trucks from it by applying to the state for a restriction.
"(That's) certainly on the table," said First Selectman Kevin Christie. "I think physical deterrents are probably more impactful than signage."
As for what that deterrent is, most people News 12 spoke to said it does not necessarily need to be on the bridge - saying some sort of barrier on either side of it, which could potentially be moved in an emergency, could also work.