Sotomayor pushes back on racial bias charges

(AP) - It was almost as if the judge were on trial.Answering for her own past statements, Sonia Sotomayor battled herway through a grueling day of intense and sometimes criticalquestioning by senators.

News 12 Staff

Jul 15, 2009, 1:05 AM

Updated 5,387 days ago

Share:

Sotomayor pushes back on racial bias charges
(AP) - It was almost as if the judge were on trial.Answering for her own past statements, Sonia Sotomayor battled herway through a grueling day of intense and sometimes criticalquestioning by senators.
But there was little question of the verdict: She's all butcertain to win confirmation to the Supreme Court.
Sotomayor pushed back vigorously Tuesday against Republicancharges that she would bring bias and a liberal agenda to her seatas the first Hispanic woman on the court, insisting repeatedly shewould be impartial as GOP senators tried to undercut her with herwords from past speeches.
There is little doubt that President Barack Obama's first highcourt choice - with solid backing from the Democrats and theirlopsided Senate majority - will be confirmed. Sen. Patrick Leahy,Democratic chairman of the Judiciary Committee, said as much - andpredicted she would receive at least some Republican backing.
Sotomayor backed away from perhaps the most damaging words thathad been brought up since Obama nominated her seven weeks ago - a2001 comment suggesting that a "wise Latina" judge would usuallyreach better conclusions than a white man. She called the remark"a rhetorical flourish that fell flat."
She also distanced herself from the man who nominated her, afterRepublican Sen. Jon Kyl asked whether Sotomayor shared Obama's view- stated when he was a senator - that in some cases, the keydeterminant is "what is in the judge's heart."
Republicans sounded unconvinced by Sotomayor's defense.
"I am very troubled that you would repeatedly over a decade ormore make statements" like the one in 2001, Sessions said.
During her first chance to answer questions publicly, Sotomayorstopped short of calling the right to abortion settled law but alsosaid, "All precedents of the Supreme Court I consider settled lawsubject to" great deference but not absolute. Under repeatedquestioning, she said she'd have an open mind on gun rights.
She also defended her most frequently criticized ruling: adecision by a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court ofAppeals last year to dismiss the claim of white firefighters in NewHaven, Conn., who alleged racial discrimination after being deniedpromotions.
On gun rights, Republicans and Democrats alike questionedSotomayor about her view of whether the Second Amendment protectionagainst curbs on the right to keep and bear arms applied to states.
Her response showed Sotomayor - and the White House coaches whohave helped prepare her for the hearings - is cognizant of thepolitical potency of the issue.


More from News 12
2:38
'The champs are here.' Around 60,000 pour into Hartford for UConn Huskies victory parade

'The champs are here.' Around 60,000 pour into Hartford for UConn Huskies victory parade

2:04
Scattered severe storms possible Sunday night in Connecticut

Scattered severe storms possible Sunday night in Connecticut

2:58
Yale doctor dedicates research on nicotine addiction to her father who died of lung cancer

Yale doctor dedicates research on nicotine addiction to her father who died of lung cancer

0:28
Israel hails ‘success’ in blocking Iran’s unprecedented attack. Biden now seeks diplomatic response

Israel hails ‘success’ in blocking Iran’s unprecedented attack. Biden now seeks diplomatic response

0:28
Play ball! Opening day for North End Little League celebrates Bridgeport team's 70th year

Play ball! Opening day for North End Little League celebrates Bridgeport team's 70th year

0:33
State police: Danbury man drove the wrong way on I-84, struck police cruiser

State police: Danbury man drove the wrong way on I-84, struck police cruiser

0:22
 State police aim to ID thieves who stole shampoo, shaving products from Litchfield CVS

State police aim to ID thieves who stole shampoo, shaving products from Litchfield CVS

1:35
CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

0:22
New data shows increase in traffic stops throughout Connecticut

New data shows increase in traffic stops throughout Connecticut

3:06
U.S Army veteran from Bridgeport says he was wrongfully convicted in Kuwait

U.S Army veteran from Bridgeport says he was wrongfully convicted in Kuwait

2:05
Age of Reason toy store to close after more than 40 years in downtown Westport

Age of Reason toy store to close after more than 40 years in downtown Westport

0:21
Police: 2 NY residents charged for selling illegal THC products at Norwalk smoke shop

Police: 2 NY residents charged for selling illegal THC products at Norwalk smoke shop

2:20
Pets or food? CT could allow farms to raise rabbit meat

Pets or food? CT could allow farms to raise rabbit meat

2:21
Westport fire department reminds community about cold water safety

Westport fire department reminds community about cold water safety

UConn men's basketball player Donovan Clingan declares for the NBA draft

UConn men's basketball player Donovan Clingan declares for the NBA draft

0:18
Car crashes into bagel store in Fairfield

Car crashes into bagel store in Fairfield

0:32
Darien police swear in new police chief

Darien police swear in new police chief

0:14
Police: Juvenile facing charges for vandalizing the little red schoolhouse in Newtown

Police: Juvenile facing charges for vandalizing the little red schoolhouse in Newtown

3:11
Connecticut lawmakers consider bill that would ban use of drones made by some foreign countries

Connecticut lawmakers consider bill that would ban use of drones made by some foreign countries

0:46
Sen. Blumenthal warns taxpayers of IRS scams

Sen. Blumenthal warns taxpayers of IRS scams